Loading...

Abby's Legendary Pizza

About

  • 3.7 ( 50 reviews)
  • $$, $$$

Abby's Pizza is a hometown tradition, with a family friendly atmosphere, spacious seating, and the freshest ingredients available. Located on Main Street, our friendly staff is ready to provide you with truly legendary pizza and ah-mazing service! Come in and experience the best pizza Myrtle Creek has to offer!

Day of the Week Opening Hours
Monday 11:00 - 22:00
Tuesday 11:00 - 22:00
Wednesday 11:00 - 22:00
Thursday 11:00 - 22:00
Friday 11:00 - 23:00
Saturday 11:00 - 23:00
Sunday 11:00 - 22:00

Cuisines

  • 🍕 Pizza

Dining Options

  • Wheelchair Accessible
  • 🍱 Lunch
  • 🍽️ Dinner

Recommended Reviews

5
48%
4
16%
3
14%
2
4%
1
18%
3.7
50 reviews
😍
Leif Webb
2018-11-13 on google

Always fun going to Abby's. Staff was excellent and the pizza was great. The potatoes were amazing though...

😍
Chris Colburn
2018-10-25 on google

Great customer service. Large servings, lots of meat. Nice salad bar. Fresh veggies

😀
Laura fletcher
2018-09-19 on google

Hoping to get to be part of the team

😍
Jaqueline Billings
2018-09-07 on google

Always consistently great pizza at every Abby's!

😍
anne dir
2018-07-18 on google

It had great food great atmosphere and great staff. We didnt wait too terribly long for our food and it was hot good a lots of it. Yum yum if i could give more stars I would

😍
MICROSOFT HQ
2018-07-03 on google

Love the food you guys should try the Garlic Knots there are Amazing! Got something after driving state to state WORTH IT.

😍
Brittney Hartley
2018-05-16 on google

Amazing pizza! And great staff!

😀
lori Gurney
2018-05-14 on google

Best fried chicken 😁

😕
Beth Monte
2018-05-03 on google

The pizza comes Luke warm, we had heart burn all day

😍
Sherry Palumbo
2018-04-25 on google

Customer service was great. They help you with any questions that you have. The place was very clean. Salad bar was fresh and very tasty . The food was very yummy . Service was excellent.

🙂
Angie Frazier
2018-02-27 on google

Not the best however definitely not the worst pizza place around. Pizza seems to be getting more and more expensive each time I go in there tho

😕
Bonnie
2018-02-05 on google

the only reason we go here is because of the fire place. everything else is average if that.

😀
Brenda Jones
2018-01-15 on google

Roasted Garlic chicken pizza is the bomb! YumO

😍
Linda Sipple
2017-10-27 on google

Best pizza a d great for family get togethers.

😍
Tamara Webster
2017-10-24 on google

Great first experience! I was visiting from Omaha and went here with my family who raved about the pizza and now I know why. We were a large group so we ordered one of each kind and they were all really good! The Greek veggie was a huge hit. I personally would add pepperoni to it but that's just me. I can't wait for my left over pizza for breakfast. Highly recommend!

😀
DeeDee Rohrer
2017-10-09 on google

Good but not "legendary". Would go again though.

😍
Joy Ward
2017-08-23 on google

Good pizza and the staff are polite and provide good quality service.

😍
Richard Strom
2017-08-23 on google

Great pizza as all locations and salad bar.

😕
Brenda
2017-08-03 on google

Worse fajita pizza I ever had

😀
Todd Richardson
2017-07-23 on google

This place seems very clean on the inside well cap up. Restrooms were clean when I went in to use them. Food came out good and tasty and enjoyed it had the bacon bacon cheddar special would order it again. The only thing I noticed was there's a lot of spider webs on the chandeliers. Other than that I would come back to this place an order again.

😍
Audrey Heggstrom
2017-07-16 on google

People are so friendly and food is great.

😍
Flash Sabin
2017-07-11 on google

Great food! Good Beer! Awsome service! And a breath takeing view!

😍
Chels B
2017-06-24 on google

Super great service

😍
Rachel Nehf
2017-06-15 on google

This is The Best Pizza in the World!!

😍
Ronda Vis
2017-06-09 on google

Clean, smelled good, bigger inside then I expected. The staff was great and then they brought my Sicillian pizza. Holy smokes that pizza was awesome. I will be back. Well worth the 13 hour drive to get there. Loved it. My hubby got a meaty veggie pizza and he loved it too. They are not tight with the toppings and the crust was great. Not too thick and not soggy. Great experience, thank you we are looking forward to many more of your pizzas. YUM!

😍
Kim norton
2017-05-18 on google

Shaun makes the perfect vegetarian garden pizza w white sauce! Great service and very clean.

🙂
Owen Lloyd
2017-05-04 on google

I grew up with Abby's. Pizza is decent, but wildly overpriced. Avoid the "white sauce" which seems hardly different from mayonnaise.

😀
Jerry O'Sullivan
2017-04-15 on google

Pizza is good. The prices are a bit high but the food is worth eating.

😕
Jeanne Davis
2017-03-18 on google

The entire pizza was under-cooked. The spuds were good.

🙂
Sandra S.
2017-02-22 on google

Pizza was good. Prices too high. $42 for 2 pizzas, one was a small. I had heard that they sent out $5 to $7 coupons on a regular basis so I signed up for the E-club. I was kind of disappointed that all I got was a free soft drink with the purchase of dine-in order. I was doing take-out that night. You think there would be something more for joining.

😐
Surreal Artwork2016
2017-02-07 on google

I placed an order at 4:50 today. It didn’t arrive tell 7pm . It was ice cooled and the wrong order too.

🙂
David Smith
2017-01-27 on google

Make sure you check your pizza. They didn't add jalapinos to it as I ordered.

😕
Kena Burke
2017-01-15 on google

We decided after parking next to the blue building which is Napa parts store(we had never been to MYRTLE CREEK), we were traveling with the dogs and parked where were not in any way gonna be in anyones way, it just so happened i forgot diapers in rig and my husband had ran out to the rig and SOME GENTLEMAN COMES OUT TELLS MY HUSBAND THEY WERE GETTING READY TO HAVE US TOWED.....we were not parked at Abby's or close to the building and obviously he saw us get out and walk to the HotRod diner, yet wow, not impressed by his completely unkind behavior.

😍
Gary Kuhre
2016-11-20 on google

Even though it was started by my wifes 2nd cousin Abby Broughton.....has no baring on my 5 star love for Abbys....been eating it for almost 50 years.

😍
Ed Steller
2016-10-19 on google

Good pizza and wings. Worker were on the ball and very professional.

🙂
Richard Olson
2016-10-16 on google

A bit spendy, but usually good quality great variety and great taste. Employees are helpful and nice.

😀
Joshua Easley
2016-10-01 on google

Great pizza! But wish they had a game room for the kids.

😕
Mike Rosas
2016-09-23 on google

Its been over a month since I've eaten there. On the 25th of June I review Abby, with my dissatisfaction with the entire meal in general, from soggy crust, to missing toppings, and a flabby salad bar that were ordered. I was assured by some generic auto reply from corporate that they have a 100% guarantee, and that I should send an emai to abbysocial with date, time, and what went wrong, and they haven't done anything to make it right as stated in their auto reply. Here we are 3 weeks later after taking the time to write them about my experiance, and still nothing. Dont get me wrong, Abby's does amazing things with pizza, but there guarantee is garbage, and corporates attempted smokescreen to overshadow a negative review with promises to make it right have no merit. Very disappointed, we eat at Abbys at least once a week, thinking we might need to take a break......very dissapointed..

😀
Elsie Bittle
2016-09-17 on google

Very good food. Great service

😐
Alexander Gray
2016-08-18 on google

I had a pepperoni pizza along with some cheese breadsticks.The pepperoni pizza was to be expected from a restaurant chain, not something that will be good, compared to other, smaller pizza places that make everything fresh.The breadsticks were awful. I ordered 3 and got 6, but that honestly makes it worse. It looked like it had multiple different cheeses on it but I couldn't taste a single one. It was so bland it was the equivalent of eating seasoned cardboard. If you are dying of hunger and this place is nearby, go for it. In any other situation I would highly recommend any other pizza place in the area.

😍
Charlena Delgado
2016-07-12 on google

We visit our grandchildren very year or very other year, and we make it a point to stop by Myrtle Creek Abby's on the way in or the way out. Always great service. The Pizza Chicken and Spuds are AWESOME!!! We have also had great service. We will definitely be by on our way out back to California on the 6/16/2018. Side note after a 14+ hour drive up we are so happy to have some ABBY'S. PLEASE KEEP IT UP ABBY'S LEGENDARY PIZZA.

🙂
Lorenzo Mafia
2016-07-06 on google

Seems like every time we have ordered in the last year we've gotten the worse product and customer service ever. We have lived in this community for over 30 years and have eaten at Abby's often through out the years , it's disconcerting. We just ordered again and the person on the other end of the phone was so rude. Customer service skills out the window!

😕
Judy Eddleman
2016-05-27 on google

Our first pizza was served raw. The second one has almost mo sauce and was definitely the wirst food I ever tasted in my life and I'm almost 60. None of my party will ever eat here again!

😍
Brittney Lane
2016-05-26 on google

Best friend works here so maybe I'm bias but I've gone here many times as a child and teenager after football games etc always been very clean and friendly staff...

😕
George Montgomery
2016-05-16 on google

My wife an i are in our 60's wanted a taco pizza an that was their giant special 21.95 we wanted a medium taco pizza and they would not give us the medium pizza for the giant pizza price. What a waste. Counter personel poor attitude when we really tried to work with them. Very very little meat on the pizza. Flavor ok but not worth experience. No more abbys😟

😍
Simpson Simpson
2016-05-14 on google

Great food, excellent service

😍
Michelle Baraby
2016-03-03 on google

Love there pizza

😍
Mike Kelley
2016-02-19 on google

best pizza ever

😕
Robert VanHeck
2016-01-20 on google

Closed at 10pm when online it said 11 pm

🙂
Ron rushford
2016-01-06 on google

Overall good pizza and decent service a bit speedy for pizza and salad but what do you expect for a small town with a big name pizza place

Questions & Answers

I love the special. Small pizza made anyway you like, salad from a fresh salad bar & drink.?

They do deliver.
Top